Prompt Library

Would You Rather Prompts That Start Actual Arguments

30 copy-paste prompts

30 ready-to-use would you rather prompts sorted by mood — funny rounds, genuinely impossible hard-mode choices, kid-safe classroom questions, and deep ones that derail the whole evening.

In short: This page contains 30 copy-paste ready prompts, organized into 5 categories with a description and pro tip for each. The first 5 prompts are free instantly, no signup needed. Hand-curated and tested by the AI Academy team.

By Louis Corneloup · Founder, Techpresso

Last updated August 28, 2026·Hand-curated & tested by the AI Academy team

Funny

6 prompts

Honk or Moo

1/30

✨ What it does

This prompt asks whether you would rather honk like a goose every time you enter a room or moo loudly every time you sit down. Pick a side out loud, then let people count how often they actually sit versus walk in.

Would you rather honk like a goose every time you enter a room or moo loudly every time you sit down?

💡

Pro tip: Twist: the sound volume matches your stress level that day. Watch everyone switch answers.

Toddler Hands or T-Rex Arms

2/30

✨ What it does

This prompt asks whether you would rather have toddler-sized hands or arms that cannot bend at the elbow. Choose one, then try eating or typing the handicap so the room can see the problem.

Would you rather have tiny toddler-sized hands or arms that can't bend at the elbow?

💡

Pro tip: Make each player physically demonstrate their morning routine with their chosen limitation before locking in.

Out-Loud Thoughts

3/30

✨ What it does

This prompt asks whether you would rather wear thought subtitles all day or let everyone hear your inner monologue for one hour. Say which one scares you more, then notice what that answer gives away.

Would you rather have all your thoughts appear in subtitles above your head or have everyone hear your internal monologue for one hour a day?

💡

Pro tip: Variant: you get to choose the hour. Suddenly half the room switches to the monologue option.

Glitter or Kazoo

4/30

✨ What it does

This prompt asks whether you would rather sneeze glitter or have your laugh replaced by a kazoo forever. Take a side, then hear out the allergy, cleanup, and dignity arguments before you lock it in.

Would you rather sneeze glitter or have your laugh replaced by a kazoo sound forever?

💡

Pro tip: Twist: the glitter color is randomized daily and the kazoo gets louder the funnier the joke is.

Birthday Clothes

5/30

✨ What it does

This prompt asks whether you would rather wear a wedding dress or tuxedo every day for a year or a swimsuit to every formal event. Audit your real calendar first, then pick frequency versus intensity.

Would you rather wear a full wedding dress or tuxedo every day for a year or wear a swimsuit to every formal event for a year?

💡

Pro tip: Variant for the office crowd: it includes job interviews and video calls. Cameras mandatory.

Slow-Motion Walk

6/30

✨ What it does

This prompt asks whether you would rather walk everywhere in dramatic slow motion or sprint everywhere with no in-between. Weigh looking cool against being on time, then commit before you explain.

Would you rather walk everywhere in dramatic slow motion or sprint at full speed everywhere you go, no in-between?

💡

Pro tip: Twist: epic movie music plays during the slow motion. This flips almost everyone.

Prompts get you started. Tutorials level you up.

A growing library of 300+ hands-on AI tutorials. New tutorials added every week.

Start 7-Day Free Trial

Impossible Choices (Hard Mode)

6 prompts

Rewind or Pause

7/30

✨ What it does

This prompt asks whether you would rather rewind life ten seconds once a day or pause time for ten minutes once a day. List what you would actually do with each power, then choose the one you would use.

Would you rather be able to rewind your life ten seconds once per day or pause time for ten minutes once per day?

💡

Pro tip: Hard-mode twist: every use ages you one extra day. Watch the daily users become monthly users.

Truth or Silence

8/30

✨ What it does

This prompt asks whether you would rather be unable to lie or go silent whenever you want to lie. Sit with the trap for a minute, then pick knowing the second option still broadcasts the cover-up.

Would you rather be incapable of lying or incapable of speaking whenever you want to lie?

💡

Pro tip: Test it live: ask each chooser an uncomfortable question and make them respond under their chosen rule.

Known Stranger

9/30

✨ What it does

This prompt asks whether you would rather have everyone learn your most embarrassing memory on meeting you, or instantly learn theirs. Decide if you want privacy or that knowledge, then say whether you could still make eye contact.

Would you rather everyone you meet instantly know your most embarrassing memory or you instantly know theirs?

💡

Pro tip: Twist: the memory plays as a 5-second video, not a summary. Choices get re-evaluated immediately.

Restart at 10

10/30

✨ What it does

This prompt asks whether you would rather restart at age 10 with what you know now or skip ahead ten years with nothing changed but the date. Answer before you justify it, then notice whether you think the best years are behind or ahead.

Would you rather restart life at age 10 with everything you know now or skip ahead 10 years with nothing changed but the date?

💡

Pro tip: Add the catch: in the restart, you can't tell anyone what you know. The lonely-genius problem changes minds.

One Perfect Skill

11/30

✨ What it does

This prompt asks whether you would rather be the world's best at one thing nobody cares about or mediocre at everything people admire. Bargain over what counts as useless, then pick excellence versus relevance.

Would you rather be the best in the world at one thing nobody cares about or mediocre at everything people admire?

💡

Pro tip: Make each player name their actual useless skill before choosing. Specifics make the choice real.

Forget or Be Forgotten

12/30

✨ What it does

This prompt asks whether you would rather forget every book and movie you have loved or have everyone forget every accomplishment you have. Say which record you live on, memory or recognition, then hear the other side out.

Would you rather forget every book and movie you've ever loved or have everyone forget every accomplishment you've ever achieved?

💡

Pro tip: Hard-mode variant: in option one, you also forget that you forgot. The horror lands a beat later.

For Kids & Classrooms

6 prompts

Dino or Dragon Pet

13/30

✨ What it does

This prompt asks kids whether they would rather have a dog-sized dinosaur or a hamster-sized dragon. Let them draft care plans, then decide if tiny fire still counts.

Would you rather have a pet dinosaur the size of a dog or a pet dragon the size of a hamster?

💡

Pro tip: Extension activity: have kids draw their pet and write three rules for taking care of it.

Trampoline Floor

14/30

✨ What it does

This prompt asks whether they would rather have a trampoline bedroom floor or a slide instead of stairs. Let the class work out sleep, homework, and how you climb a slide, then vote.

Would you rather have a trampoline floor in your bedroom or a slide instead of stairs in your house?

💡

Pro tip: Ask the follow-up: "What's the one problem with your choice, and how would you fix it?"

Talk to Toys or Plants

15/30

✨ What it does

This prompt asks whether they would rather have talking toys or walking plants. Hear the secret-telling and travel theories, then use the better argument as a writing warm-up.

Would you rather your toys could talk or your plants could walk?

💡

Pro tip: Classroom variant: split into teams and have each side argue why the OTHER choice would cause chaos.

Snow Day or Beach Day

16/30

✨ What it does

This prompt asks whether they would rather have snow every weekend or beach weather every weekend, all year. Listen for the kid who picks snow for cancelled school, then take a class vote.

Would you rather it snowed every weekend or was beach weather every weekend, all year long?

💡

Pro tip: Turn it into a graphing exercise: tally the class vote and chart the results by reason.

Invisible or Flying (Recess Edition)

17/30

✨ What it does

This prompt asks whether they would rather be invisible only at recess or fly only inside the school. Let them map hallway flight paths on the board, then pick a power with the limits still on.

Would you rather be invisible only during recess or able to fly only inside your school?

💡

Pro tip: Add the rule: you have to explain one GOOD deed and one funny deed you'd do with your power.

Class Pet President

18/30

✨ What it does

This prompt asks whether the class would rather have a homework-helping monkey or a cleaning robot that tells terrible jokes. Weigh help versus annoyance out loud, then have the room choose.

Would you rather your class got a pet monkey that helps with homework or a robot that does all the cleaning but tells terrible jokes?

💡

Pro tip: Have students write one joke the robot would tell. Collect them; you now own a class joke book.

Like these prompts? There are full tutorials behind them.

Learn the workflows, not just the prompts. 300+ easy-to-follow tutorials inside AI Academy — and growing every week.

Try AI Academy Free

Deep & Philosophical

6 prompts

Map or Compass

19/30

✨ What it does

This prompt asks whether you would rather know your purpose but not how to reach it, or have every skill and no aim. Defend the choice with a real chapter of your life, then sit with what that reveals.

Would you rather know your purpose in life but not how to achieve it or have every skill you need but no idea what to aim at?

💡

Pro tip: Follow-up: ask which one describes the person's life right now. That's where the conversation actually starts.

Borrowed Greatness

20/30

✨ What it does

This prompt asks whether you would rather make one masterpiece credited to someone else or be credited for a masterpiece you did not make. Split on making versus recognition, then listen to the defenses.

Would you rather create one masterpiece everyone credits to someone else or be credited for a masterpiece you didn't create?

💡

Pro tip: Raise the stakes: the masterpiece changes the world. Does the answer change when the work matters more?

Edited Past

21/30

✨ What it does

This prompt asks whether you would rather remember your life exactly as it happened or remember it slightly better than it was. Pick accuracy or a kinder edit, then say whether you think you already chose one.

Would you rather remember your life exactly as it happened or remember it slightly better than it was?

💡

Pro tip: Variant: everyone around you gets the same edit. Shared rosy memory or private true one?

Hard Truth Machine

22/30

✨ What it does

This prompt asks whether you would rather know the honest answer to one question about yourself or about one other person. Decide who you would ask about, then notice that the who may be the real tell.

Would you rather know the honest answer to one question about yourself or about one other person in your life?

💡

Pro tip: Nobody has to say their question out loud — but ask who chose "self" versus "other" and let the ratio speak.

Legacy or Presence

23/30

✨ What it does

This prompt asks whether you would rather be deeply important to five people or mildly important to five million. Argue intimacy versus scale, then test the fame side with a name nobody remembers.

Would you rather be deeply important to 5 people or mildly important to 5 million?

💡

Pro tip: Flip it: which one do you actually behave like you want? The gap between answers is the discussion.

Question or Answer

24/30

✨ What it does

This prompt asks whether you would rather have the answer to one universe question or a guarantee that humanity finds all the answers after you are gone. Choose personal knowing versus patience for the species, then say if a private answer would feel like knowledge or madness.

Would you rather have the answer to any one question about the universe or the guarantee that humanity eventually finds all the answers after you're gone?

💡

Pro tip: Make everyone state their one question first. Half the group changes sides after hearing the options.

Food & Lifestyle

6 prompts

Breakfast Lock-In

25/30

✨ What it does

This prompt asks whether you would rather eat breakfast food for every meal or never eat breakfast food again. Push the all-or-nothing frame, then see who still wants pancakes at dinner 400.

Would you rather eat breakfast food for every meal or never be allowed to eat breakfast food again?

💡

Pro tip: Define "breakfast food" first as a group — the fight over whether pizza counts IS the game.

Spice or Ice

26/30

✨ What it does

This prompt asks whether you would rather have every meal slightly too spicy or every drink lukewarm forever. Pick the daily misery you could live with, then find your unlikely allies.

Would you rather everything you eat be slightly too spicy or everything you drink be lukewarm forever?

💡

Pro tip: Twist: "slightly" upgrades to "moderately" every birthday. Long-term thinkers recalculate fast.

Chef or Cleaner

27/30

✨ What it does

This prompt asks whether you would rather have a mediocre private chef or a house cleaner who only comes while you are home and narrates everything. Weigh bad food against awkward company, then choose which luxury you would still want.

Would you rather have a private chef who's a mediocre cook or a house cleaner who only comes when you're home and narrates everything?

💡

Pro tip: Variant: the chef CAN become great, but only if you eat the bad food without complaint for one full year.

One City or Fifty

28/30

✨ What it does

This prompt asks whether you would rather live in your favorite city and never travel or travel constantly and never stay more than two weeks. Ask where the dentist and the friendships live, then pick roots or motion.

Would you rather live in your favorite city but never travel again or travel constantly but never stay anywhere longer than two weeks?

💡

Pro tip: Make it concrete: each player names their actual city before choosing. Abstract answers don't count.

Phone-Free Weekends

29/30

✨ What it does

This prompt asks whether you would rather give up your phone every weekend or get only 30 minutes of internet each weekday. Negotiate what still counts, then notice which apps you tried to save.

Would you rather give up your phone every weekend or be limited to 30 minutes of internet per weekday?

💡

Pro tip: Challenge round: whoever picks weekend-free has to actually try it once and report back next game night.

Free Food or Free Flights

30/30

✨ What it does

This prompt asks whether you would rather have free restaurant meals for life or free flights anywhere for life. Run the daily-versus-rare math out loud, then pick one instead of trying to scheme both.

Would you rather have free restaurant meals for life or free flights anywhere for life?

💡

Pro tip: Close the loophole upfront: flights don't include hotels, and meals are for you alone — no feeding friends.

Free tool

Prompt Optimizer

Turn a rough idea into a structured, professional AI prompt.

Try it free →

Frequently Asked Questions

The best would you rather questions make both options genuinely costly or genuinely appealing — a 50/50 split is the goal. If everyone picks the same side in two seconds, the question failed. Add a constraint or a twist until smart people disagree.

Hard-mode questions trade two things people refuse to rank: memory versus recognition, truth versus comfort, purpose versus ability. Try "Would you rather forget every book you've loved or have everyone forget your accomplishments?" — almost nobody answers fast.

Aim for absurd-but-visual scenarios: honking when entering rooms, sneezing glitter, dramatic slow-motion walking. The funniest questions force players to imagine living the consequence daily — the comedy is in the logistics, not the punchline.

Kid questions work best with concrete, imaginable stakes: pet dinosaurs, trampoline floors, talking toys, snow every weekend. Avoid abstractions — kids engage when they can picture and argue the specifics, like how you'd get back UP a slide.

Take turns asking; everyone must pick a side — no "neither" allowed. The asker can demand a one-sentence defense from each player. For groups, vote simultaneously on a count of three, then let the minority side argue their case. Disagreement is the game.

Yes — ChatGPT and similar tools are good at it if you specify audience and difficulty: "20 hard-mode would you rather questions for adults where both options are bad." Ask it to explain the trade-off in each one, then keep only the questions where you genuinely hesitate.

Prompts are the starting line. Tutorials are the finish.

A growing library of 300+ hands-on tutorials on ChatGPT, Claude, Midjourney, and 50+ AI tools. New tutorials added every week.

Start 7-Day Free Trial See how AI Academy teaches AI for teams

7-day free trial. Cancel anytime.

Browse All Prompt Collections

Popular prompt collections

AI Photo Editing Prompts ChatGPT Jailbreak Prompt Best ChatGPT Prompts Funny Hinge Prompts ChatGPT Caricature Prompts