Prompt Library

Would You Rather Writing Prompts (That Force Real Choice)

30 copy-paste prompts

30 copy-paste "would you rather" writing prompts that force genuine decision-making. Build argument muscles, generate personal essays, and produce honest writing through structured choice.

In short: This page contains 30 copy-paste ready prompts, organized into 6 categories with a description and pro tip for each. The first 15 prompts are free instantly — no signup needed. Hand-curated and tested by the AI Academy team.

By Louis Corneloup · Founder, Techpresso
Last updated ·Hand-curated & tested by the AI Academy team

Easy Warmups

5 prompts

Always Hot or Always Cold?

1/30

Would you rather always feel hot OR always feel cold? Write your choice. Defend it with 3 specific reasons. Address why the other option might appeal to others.

Easy decision warmup with structure.

💡

Pro tip: Easy questions teach the structure (claim + reasons + counter). Build the muscle on low-stakes choices.

Read Minds or Talk to Animals?

2/30

Would you rather read minds OR talk to animals? Choose. Write 2-3 paragraphs explaining your choice with specific examples of when each ability would be useful or harmful.

Power-comparison decision prompt.

💡

Pro tip: Both options have appeal AND drawback. Forces real weighing, not slam-dunk choosing.

Live Without Music or Movies?

3/30

Would you rather give up music OR movies for the rest of your life? Choose. Write your choice with personal examples — specific songs you'd miss vs specific films.

Personal-loss comparison prompt.

💡

Pro tip: Personal examples make the choice real. "Bohemian Rhapsody specifically" beats "music in general."

Time Travel: Past or Future?

4/30

Would you rather travel to the past OR the future? Pick a specific destination (which past year? which future year?) and write your choice with reasoning.

Time-direction decision with specificity.

💡

Pro tip: Forcing specific year makes the abstract concrete. "1922" reveals more than "the past."

Coffee or Tea Forever?

5/30

Would you rather drink only coffee OR only tea for the rest of your life? Pick. Defend with sensory detail (taste, ritual, social use). 2-3 paragraphs.

Sensory choice prompt.

💡

Pro tip: Sensory-defense writing builds descriptive muscles. "Coffee at 7am after a hard week" beats "I like coffee."

Prompts get you started. Tutorials level you up.

A growing library of 300+ hands-on AI tutorials. New tutorials added every week.

Start 7-Day Free Trial

Hard Decisions

5 prompts

Know When You'll Die or How?

6/30

Would you rather know the EXACT date you'll die OR know HOW you'll die (but not when)? Choose. Write 3-4 paragraphs exploring how each knowledge would change how you live.

Mortality decision prompt.

💡

Pro tip: Heavy topic produces deep writing. Push past initial reaction; sit with the question.

Save 1 Stranger or 5 Strangers?

7/30

Would you rather save 1 stranger you can see OR 5 strangers you can't see? Choose. Write 3-4 paragraphs exploring why one feels different from the other (even though math is clear).

Trolley-problem decision prompt.

💡

Pro tip: Classic ethics dilemma. The "they're both strangers" framing forces engagement with the visibility difference.

Lose Your Memories or Lose Your Future Memory?

8/30

Would you rather lose all memories of your past OR lose the ability to make new memories from now on? Choose. Write 3-4 paragraphs exploring the loss in each case.

Memory-loss decision prompt.

💡

Pro tip: Forces engagement with what memory IS. Past-self vs future-self trade-off.

Live Forever Alone or Die at 50 Loved?

9/30

Would you rather live forever but always alone OR die at 50 surrounded by people who love you? Choose. Write 3-4 paragraphs.

Length-vs-quality of life prompt.

💡

Pro tip: Forces clarification of what makes life worth living. Strong personal essay material.

Be Right or Be Kind?

10/30

Would you rather be RIGHT (when you are) and ruin a relationship OR be KIND (compromising the truth) and preserve the relationship? Choose. Write 3-4 paragraphs about a specific situation.

Truth vs kindness moral choice.

💡

Pro tip: Real moral tension. Many people want both; the prompt forces choosing.

Career + Life Decisions

5 prompts

Job You Love or Job That Pays Well?

11/30

Would you rather have a job you LOVE that barely pays OR a job you HATE that pays $300k? Choose. Write 3-4 paragraphs exploring how the choice would shape your life.

Work-meaning vs work-money prompt.

💡

Pro tip: Universal trade-off prompt. Pushes engagement with what work means to the writer.

Famous or Anonymous?

12/30

Would you rather be famous (recognized everywhere) but always observed OR completely anonymous (no recognition ever)? Choose. Write 3-4 paragraphs exploring the trade-off.

Visibility-vs-privacy prompt.

💡

Pro tip: Modern relevance — social media has made this question more pressing.

Work Remote Forever or In-Person Forever?

13/30

Would you rather work fully remote for the rest of your career OR fully in-person for the rest of your career? No hybrid. Choose. Write 3-4 paragraphs about why.

Modern work-arrangement prompt.

💡

Pro tip: Highly current topic — strong opinions on both sides. Engaging for working-age writers.

Start Over or Stay the Course?

14/30

You're mid-career. Would you rather start completely over in a different field OR stay in your current path even if you're uncertain about it? Choose. Write 3-4 paragraphs about the costs of each.

Career-path decision prompt.

💡

Pro tip: Personal essay material. Most working adults have considered both directions.

Work Less or Earn More?

15/30

Would you rather work 20 hours a week and earn $50k OR work 60 hours a week and earn $200k? Choose. Write 3-4 paragraphs about what you'd do with the differences (in money OR time).

Time-vs-money prompt.

💡

Pro tip: The "what would you do with the difference" forces real engagement. What does extra time/money actually buy you?

Relationship + Identity

5 prompts

Loyal Friend or Honest Friend?

16/30

Would you rather have a friend who is always LOYAL (defends you no matter what) OR always HONEST (tells you the hard truth)? Choose. Write 3-4 paragraphs.

Friend-quality choice prompt.

💡

Pro tip: Surface choice obvious; engagement with both deepens. Most want both; prompt forces priority.

Soulmate Far Away or Mediocre Partner Nearby?

17/30

Would you rather find your perfect partner who lives across the world OR an okay-but-not-great partner who's nearby and convenient? Choose. Write 3-4 paragraphs about the trade-off.

Compatibility vs proximity prompt.

💡

Pro tip: Forces engagement with what relationship work means. The "okay-but-convenient" option is real and tempting.

Be Universally Liked or Have 5 Best Friends?

18/30

Would you rather be liked by everyone (medium) OR have 5 deep friendships (intense)? Choose. Write 3-4 paragraphs about the trade-off.

Breadth-vs-depth in relationships prompt.

💡

Pro tip: Most people claim depth; many actually live for breadth. Honest engagement reveals which you actually are.

Know What People Really Think of You or Never Wonder?

19/30

Would you rather know exactly what every person thinks of you OR never wonder again? Choose. Write 3-4 paragraphs.

Self-perception vs peace prompt.

💡

Pro tip: Forces engagement with the cost of either. Knowing might destroy you; not wondering might be liberation.

Forgive Without Apology or Apologize Without Forgiveness?

20/30

Would you rather forgive someone who never apologizes OR have to apologize to someone who refuses to forgive you? Choose. Write 3-4 paragraphs about which feels harder.

Forgiveness-cycle prompt.

💡

Pro tip: Real ethics dilemma. Both options are common life experiences; few have considered which they'd choose.

Worldly Trade-Offs

5 prompts

Solve Climate Change or Cure Cancer?

21/30

Would you rather press a button that immediately solves climate change OR cures cancer permanently? Choose. Write 3-4 paragraphs about the impact differential.

Global-impact decision prompt.

💡

Pro tip: Forces engagement with scale, time horizons, and what counts as "solving" a global problem.

Eliminate All War or Eliminate All Poverty?

22/30

Would you rather magically eliminate all war OR all poverty (one only)? Choose. Write 3-4 paragraphs about why one matters more.

Global-priority decision prompt.

💡

Pro tip: Philosophical heavy lifting. The choice reveals values about what causes most suffering.

Time Speed Up or Slow Down?

23/30

Would you rather have time speed up (your life moves twice as fast) OR slow down (your life moves half as fast) for the next 10 years? Choose. Write 3-4 paragraphs.

Time-perception decision.

💡

Pro tip: Forces engagement with what we want from time. Faster = sooner reach goals; slower = more savoring.

See the Future or Change the Past?

24/30

Would you rather see the future (but unable to change it) OR change one thing about the past (but unable to see consequences)? Choose. Write 3-4 paragraphs.

Time-power decision prompt.

💡

Pro tip: The trade-offs are clear and weighty. Both come with significant downsides.

Keep Your Brain or Keep Your Body?

25/30

Would you rather keep your current brain (memories, skills, personality) but get a different body OR keep your current body but get a different brain? Choose. Write 3-4 paragraphs.

Identity-locus decision prompt.

💡

Pro tip: Reveals where the writer locates "self" — in body or in mind. Strong philosophical exercise.

Go from copy-pasting to actually mastering AI.

AI Academy: 300+ hands-on tutorials on ChatGPT, Claude, Midjourney, and 50+ other tools. New tutorials added every week.

Start Your Free Trial

Quick + Silly

5 prompts

Pizza or Tacos Forever?

26/30

Would you rather eat ONLY pizza OR ONLY tacos for the rest of your life? Choose. Write 1-2 paragraphs with reasoning.

Quick food choice prompt.

💡

Pro tip: Easy warmup. Builds the form on low-stakes choices.

Always Speak in Rhyme or Always Speak in Whispers?

27/30

Would you rather always have to speak in rhyme OR always speak in whispers? Choose. Write 1-2 paragraphs about which would be more annoying long-term.

Silly constraint choice.

💡

Pro tip: Silly prompts loosen up writers stuck on serious topics. Useful warmups.

Have a Dragon or Have a Yacht?

28/30

Would you rather own a dragon (impressive but hungry) OR own a yacht (mundane but useful)? Choose. Write 1-2 paragraphs.

Asset choice prompt.

💡

Pro tip: The mundane vs magical choice reveals practical orientation.

Have a Trail of Music Follow You or a Cloud of Confetti?

29/30

Would you rather have a personal soundtrack play wherever you go OR have confetti fall around you whenever you walk? Choose. Write 1-2 paragraphs.

Aesthetic-life choice prompt.

💡

Pro tip: Whimsy choice — fine for warmup. Reveals personality.

Be a Cat or Be a Dog?

30/30

Would you rather live as a cat OR as a dog for one week? Choose. Write 1-2 paragraphs about your week.

Animal-life choice prompt.

💡

Pro tip: Cats vs dogs is endlessly engaging. The "one week" frame keeps it grounded.

Frequently Asked Questions

They force decisions. Most writing prompts let you avoid taking a position; "would you rather" requires choice. Choice = clarity = stronger writing.
Yes — pick easier prompts for younger kids. The decision-based structure builds early opinion writing. Adapt complexity to age.
Yes — the harder prompts (mortality, ethics, identity) produce strong personal essays. Choice + reasoning + reflection = essay structure.
Both. Classroom use with sharing produces engaged discussion. Solo journaling produces deeper personal reflection. Different strengths.
Easy warmups: 1-2 paragraphs. Hard decisions and identity prompts: 3-4 paragraphs. Personal essays from these prompts: 1-3 pages.

Prompts are the starting line. Tutorials are the finish.

A growing library of 300+ hands-on tutorials on ChatGPT, Claude, Midjourney, and 50+ AI tools. New tutorials added every week.

Start 7-Day Free TrialExplore AI for Marketers

7-day free trial. Cancel anytime.

Browse All Prompt Collections